Tuesday 16 February 2010

Tuesday's throwdown

David Woodhouse has generously contributed a guest article and I am sure you will find that it is both knowledgable and extremely applicable to weightlifting. Read, enjoy and post any questions you may have for David in the comments section below. Here is his pb Snatch by the way:



Charlie Francis and the CNS: Implications to Weightlifting--by David Woodhouse

The importance and role of the central nervous system (CNS) was first brought to my attention through reading Charlie Francis' (semi) autobiography, Speed Trap. On reflection this is a worrying statement given that I had at that point completed a BSc in Sports Science and two gym instructor courses, but that's another story...! Due to its frank discussion of drugs, Speed Trap has been dismissed by many conservative scholars but for many people it is remains the best book about elite level athletics ever written. Francis is revealed to be a highly intelligent, analytical and 'athlete focused' coach, and the passing of time has only given more credence to his more controversial claims.

Francis was himself an Olympic sprinter but is best known as the long time coach of Canadian sprinter, Ben Johnson. Johnson's performance in winning the Seoul Olympics was widely regarded as the fastest run in history until Usain Bolt broke the world record in 2008 (Johnson ran 9.79s on a softer slower track and whilst slowing to celebrate in the last 10 metres). Other notable athletes Francis worked with were Commonwealth Champions Mark McKoy and Angella Issajenko.

Charlie based much of his training philosophy around carefully managing the demands on the CNS. More specifically, his training week was modelled on the idea that the CNS requires at least 48 hours to recover from high intensity training such as sprinting, plyometrics or heavy lifting. Charlie learned of this through discussion with top (Eastern) European coaches from the early 70s. Before this most elite sprinters (including himself) in the West performed speed work on a daily basis and therefore in a constant state of CNS fatigue.

Most modern sprint coaches now prescribe speed work only on alternate days. Between speed sessions lower intensity 'tempo' running is performed as a form of active recovery. Anecdotal evidence suggests that moderate exercise can increase rate of recovery faster than rest alone. Weightlifting coaches have for years alternated heavy and light workouts and this perhaps provides a logical reason why. As an aside, in my experience, most lifters don't distinguish enough between their heavy and light sessions. They go too heavy on the light days and, due to fatigue, not heavy enough on the other days! What results is a string of moderate workouts that achieve little.

The tempo or light sessions also serve to raise general work capacity, manage body composition and can be an opportunity to address technical errors. Clearly all these benefits are equally important to the weightlifter. In my experience however, for the novice and intermediate lifter, rest actually IS better than light lifting for promoting recovery. Perhaps until the athlete has developed sufficient work capacity, general exercise such as swimming, walking or cycling may be more effective than specific lifting on 'off days'.

For elite (full time) athletes, Francis favours the following weekly template:
Monday, Wednesday & Friday: Speed & Weights
Tuesday, Thursday & Saturday: Tempo and Calisthenics

The specific track work is always given priority over strength work in the gym in the same way the competition lifts are generally given priority over squatting and pure strength exercises in weightlifting. Observant readers may notice the similarities between this program and the 'Americanised Bulgarian' program that I outlined in my previous article.

Less advanced athletes generally follow the following program:
Monday & Thursday: Speed
Tuesday & Friday: Weights (strength)
Wednesday & Saturday: Tempo

This ensures that the CNS is fully recharged for the speed sessions but cuts total work by a third (one less speed and strength workout per week). Weightlifters could apply these templates by substituting the competition lifts for speed work and squats for strength.

Why is CNS fatigue so important?.. A fatigued CNS cannot generate the frequency of nerve impulses required to activate the highest threshold motor units. As a result, the most powerful 'fast twitch' muscle fibres are not recruited and subsequently will not be trained. It is intuitive therefore that training performed in a state of CNS fatigue will be at best inefficient. If high intensity training is repeated for prolonged periods then performance will likely stagnate or decline. This state is typically described as overtraining, and causes symptoms of insomnia, irritability and involuntary muscle contractions.

Additionally, a fatigued CNS has a compromised ability to coordinate muscle action which is also detrimental to performance in any multi joint sport. Interestingly, Francis interpreted his athletes' inability to learn new skills as a sign of CNS fatigue and would, in those situations, conclude training early. If a weightlifter is making technical errors and missing warm up lifts, the coach might conclude that he has CNS fatigue and should stop or have a lighter workout.

Francis insisted that all speed work be done at maximum intensity, but that total volume per week should be less than 1600m. By the mid 80s his athletes would run over 100 metres only once per week. By training at maximum the athlete's neural adaptations were maximised and his risk of injury in competition were reduced. Clearly Francis believes intensity to be a more important, a more powerful variable than volume! He also states that a mature elite level athlete may have to reduce volume to allow further progression and also to reduce injury risk. The idea of lifting at maximum intensity was covered extensively in my last article, 'Ivan Abadjiev and the Bulgarian System'.

Francis also controversially states that CNS adaptation can be both specific and general. The former includes inter and intra muscular coordination and is specific to the exercise being performed. The latter involves a higher output (rate coding) by the CNS and leads to improvement across all exercises. So in the same way that bench press can improve sprint performance, sprinting can improve bench performance. When considering this the reader should be careful to distinguish strength improvements via neural mechanisms from those due to increases in contractile protein.

I hope this has been a thought provoking article. For further reading I suggest readers visit www.charliefrancis.com/forum for direct insight from the man himself or track down a copy of Speed Trap on ebay.


In my own training for today, I took a word of advice from the above article and had a light snappy day which should set me up for tomorrow's training day and Saturday's competition. I worked up to three singles with 95 in the Snatch. They were sharp and fast and then I worked up to a single with 110 in the Clean and Jerk. Again, very easy and I felt great afterwards. I am starting to feel more like myself which is great. I was pretty beat up over the last week and a half and it nice to feel like I have energy again. Alex showed me a few back mobility exercises that I found very helpful in my first pull and I will do them again tonight and before training tomorrow morning.

9 comments:

CathalByrd said...

Great article Dave.

"As an aside, in my experience, most lifters don't distinguish enough between their heavy and light sessions. They go too heavy on the light days and, due to fatigue, not heavy enough on the other days! What results is a string of moderate workouts that achieve little."

This is something I can relate to. My 2009, as well as being plagued by a knee injury, wasn't helped either by not including enough recovery days. What resulted was me being able to hit 90-95% most days, but because I was hitting such a high % every day I was too fatigued to deal with 97-100%+. As a result I didn't lift to my potential last year and this is something I am trying to focus on more by holding back a bit more on certain days.

Hope your prep for English C'ships is going well.

Anonymous said...

An excellent article; very interesting insight and opinions, articulately expressed. Thank you David.

Zag said...

"Chuck Norris does not suffer from CNS fatigue......He tells his CNS to shut the F*** up and get on with it!!"

Zag said...

Really enjoyed your article Mr. Woodhouse,

I would have to agree with the Birdman too, I find that myself and Baz have sometimes been to eager on light days. We tend to go heavier than we should and hence don't maximise the most out of our heavy days. It is something that has changed recently.

Training camp in Woking helped me realise how important it is to plan out your intensity's for a weekly and monthly basis. Otherwise you wont hit the 95%+ days when your supposed too!!!

It's equally important to stick to your light days. Not just go in and see how you feel for that particular day. This particular has been a big fault of mine. I have previously tried to match my light day to Barry's but the reality is that my lifts aren't as big as his so my light days must incorporate less load.

Not sure if this all makes sense but I look forward to reading speed trap.

I hear you have a new Irish lifter on your hands. He's a great bloke, I know he'll enjoy your training atmosphere!!!

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the kind comments lads.

Sami - yes Kris is ridiculously talented (and a very nice fella). He will be gunning for Byrdboy by the end of the year!

Unfortunately my lifting is in the doldrums (hip injury) but I'll get on the Anadin on Saturday and cross my fingers!

DW

bigphathar said...

Very good article. Speed trap was a great read, and the drug-use aside, his approach to coaching was pretty impressive.

Zig, Zag; Yes, you have been guilty of going too heavy on light days, Zig especially. But you both learn from your mistakes, which is more important than never making any.

See you in the morning,

Lee

Anonymous said...

BTW my little leprechaun friends. I will be in my new house in Twickenham (5 minutes from St Marys) on March 31st. There will be a free double bedroom plus a bed settee down stairs and I'd like to make my house a free hostel for any travelling weightlifters...

DW

CathalByrd said...

"BTW my little leprechaun friends."

Attitude problem...vintage Woodsy.

Barry said...

I agree Byrdie: vintage Woodso. Thanks for the invite Dave; I am looking forward to cashing in!

Post a Comment